Great Replacement Theory 101: People are fear-mongering about a “migrant caravan” again
This antisemitic “Great Replacement” theory talking point has been deadly before. Here’s what to know.
This “Great Replacement” talking point has been deadly before. We can’t let it spread again.
What’s happening: A caravan of several hundred people left Honduras on September 20 and is moving north through Mexico. In the weeks leading up to the midterms, right-wing commentators have been calling it an “invasion,” suggesting it’s timed to the election, and asking who’s really paying for it.
We’ve heard this song before: “Invasion.” “Timed to the election.” “Who’s behind it?” This is part of a well-worn playbook that claims someone is deliberately bringing immigrants in to attack America’s white majority and impact the economy, the vote, and the culture.
That is the essence of the deadly Great Replacement Theory.
The Great Replacement
The Great Replacement is a conspiracy theory claiming that white populations are being deliberately replaced by non-white immigrants as part of a secret plan by hidden elites. In its American form, those elites are often Jews.
This conspiracy turns demographic change into a secret plot by a shadowy villain, and that’s why it’s often tied directly to antisemitism. Jews are constantly being cast as the hidden hand behind insidious plots in these white nationalist fantasies.
Where it came from
The phrase we know today comes from French writer Renaud Camus, who popularized the term in his 2011 book Le Grand Replacement. But as with so many modern conspiracies, the roots are much older, including the early-1900s “race suicide” panic, Madison Grant’s 1916 The Passing of the Great Race, and decades of “white genocide” propaganda.
In Charlottesville in 2017, neo-Nazi demonstrators chanted “Jews will not replace us.” This is the replacement they were talking about.
How it spreads: Many subscribers to this conspiracy use code words like “invasion,” “globalists,” “importing voters,” and “who’s funding this?” Extremist accounts and influencers plant the seed and spread it in a way that gives the core argument legitimacy in the discourse while still maintaining plausible deniability.
In 2018, President Trump called the caravan an “invasion” and said he “wouldn’t be surprised” if George Soros was funding it. Rep. Matt Gaetz promoted the same idea. In 2021, Rep. Elise Stefanik ran ads claiming Democrats’ immigration plans would “overthrow our current electorate.”
Abroad, Viktor Orbán, Éric Zemmour, and Italy’s agriculture minister have all used versions of it. Boiling this down to left vs. right misses the mark on what the debate surrounding this conspiracy theory really is.
We’ve seen where this goes: In 2018, the question “who’s funding the caravan?” spread across conspiracist circles. The answer became “Soros” within days. The claim moved from anonymous accounts to cable news to the Oval Office.
Then, on October 27, 2018, a gunman murdered 11 worshippers at Pittsburgh’s Tree of Life synagogue. He had posted that HIAS, a Jewish refugee agency, was bringing in “invaders.” He believed the caravan was a Jewish plot, and that precipitated his murderous rampage. It was the deadliest antisemitic attack in American history.
And this isn’t an isolated incident. Great Replacement Theory has a deadly trail across multiple communities.
- Poway, 2019: 1 murdered at a synagogue.
- Christchurch, 2019: 51 murdered at two mosques. The manifesto was titled “The Great Replacement”
- El Paso, 2019: 23 murdered after a tirade about a “Hispanic invasion.”
- Buffalo, 2022: 10 Black shoppers murdered.
The connective tissue is Great Replacement fear mongering and conspiracy.
This rhetoric must be called out and condemned.